Commercial Litigation Lawyers in Melbourne

Business disputes are won on documents, not in the courtroom

A commercial dispute is rarely won by the better speech in court. It is won by the side with the cleaner paper trail, the earlier advice, and the discipline to settle when settlement makes commercial sense. Commercial litigation is risk management as much as it is legal work, and the firms that treat it that way save their clients money.

If your business is in dispute, call MK Law on 1800 130 120 today. The first call is free and the advice is straight.

The first letter you send sets the price of the whole dispute. A demand drafted by a commercial litigation lawyer frames the claim, fixes a deadline, and protects you from admissions that come back to bite at trial. A demand fired off in anger usually does the opposite. This is not the document to write yourself.

The commercial disputes we run

We act for plaintiffs and defendants across the main commercial fact patterns. Most businesses come to us with a matter that sits in more than one of these, and we run it under one strategy:

• Contract disputes. Breach, repudiation, misleading and deceptive conduct under the Australian Consumer Law, and arguments over termination, variation and damages.
• Partnership and shareholder disputes. Fall-outs between co-owners and business partners, oppression actions under section 232 of the Corporations Act, buy-outs and forced sales.
• Breach of fiduciary duty. Directors and senior employees who took opportunities, intellectual property, staff or money that belonged to the company.
• Debt recovery and statutory demands. Six-figure and seven-figure recoveries, statutory demands under section 459E of the Corporations Act, and winding-up applications where the debt is not seriously disputed.
• Property disputes. Commercial leasing fights, disputed sales of business premises, easements and adjoining-owner disputes that affect a trading business.
• Corporate governance disputes. Board deadlocks, removal of directors, access to company books, and 249D members’ meetings.
• Fraud and misrepresentation. Tracing claims, Mareva (freezing) orders, Anton Piller orders, and recovery against directors personally where the corporate veil can be lifted.
• Intellectual property disputes. Misuse of confidential information, trade-mark and brand fights, and restraint-of-trade claims when a key person leaves.

If your matter touches several of these at once, that is normal. We line them up under a single plan rather than running them as separate files.

The case is built on paper before it is argued

Most commercial disputes are decided by the documents, not the dramatics. On the first call we read what you have: the contract, the emails, the invoices, the board minutes, the messages people wish they had never sent. We tell you which facts help you, which hurt, and what is still missing. From there we frame the claim and draft the pleadings that set the terms of the fight. By the end of the call you have a written view on prospects and a clear next step, or an honest reason we would not run it.

Talk to a lawyer today

The dispute resolution ladder

Most commercial disputes move up the same ladder. Knowing which rung you are on tells you what the next move costs and what it can achieve. Alternative dispute resolution sits at the heart of it, because the large majority of commercial matters settle without a trial. Nobody should have to guess at the vocabulary while they are in the middle of it, so what commercial litigation is sets out the same rungs in plain English.

Letter of demand

A properly drafted letter of demand resolves a meaningful share of disputes inside 14 to 28 days. It frames the legal claim, sets a deadline, and signals that the next step is court. The mistake clients make is sending it themselves before getting legal advice on prospects, because admissions in the letter come back to bite at trial.

Without-prejudice negotiation

If the demand does not produce payment, the next move is a without-prejudice exchange between lawyers. “Without prejudice” means the conversation cannot be used in court. That gives both sides room to talk numbers without conceding the case. A lot of value sits in this stage.

Mediation and arbitration

Mediation is confidential, fast, and often court-ordered before trial. A good commercial mediator settles the clear majority of the disputes that reach them. Arbitration is the other main form of alternative dispute resolution: a private hearing before an arbitrator whose decision binds the parties, common where a contract requires it. The Supreme Court’s Commercial Court list usually orders the parties to mediate within a few months of pleadings closing.

Litigation

If mediation fails or the other side will not engage, we file. Pleadings, discovery, evidence and trial follow. Most matters that get filed still settle before judgment, often on the courthouse steps. We say this not to talk anyone out of court, but because pretending every matter is a trial is how clients end up with the wrong strategy and the wrong budget.

Debt recovery and statutory demands

When the debt is clear and not seriously disputed, the fastest route is often a statutory demand. A demand under section 459E of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) requires a company to pay a debt of at least $4,000 within 21 days. Ignore it, and the company is presumed insolvent, which opens the door to a winding-up application. It is one of the most effective tools in commercial debt recovery, and one of the easiest to get wrong: a demand served over a genuinely disputed debt can be set aside with costs against you. We use them where the debt is solid and reach for a letter of demand or court proceedings where it is not.

Courts and tribunals

Commercial matters in Victoria sit in one of several forums, and choosing the right one shapes both cost and speed.

The Supreme Court of Victoria, and specifically the Commercial Court list, handles complex commercial disputes, corporations matters and claims above the County Court’s jurisdiction. The judges in the Commercial Court list actively manage cases, push mediation early, and impose tight timetables. It is a fast list by Australian standards.

The County Court of Victoria (General Division) handles commercial claims up to its jurisdictional limit. It is the default forum for mid-sized contract and debt matters, and its costs are usually lower than the Supreme Court.

The Federal Court of Australia runs the corporations and consumer-law jurisdictions in parallel with the state courts. Winding-up applications, larger Australian Consumer Law claims and matters with a federal element often run here. The Federal Court’s docket system gives you one judge from filing to judgment.

The Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT) hears retail and commercial lease disputes and some consumer matters at lower cost and with less formality, though larger commercial fights belong in the courts.

The procedural rules are set by the Civil Procedure Act 2010 (Vic), which imposes overarching obligations on every party and lawyer to act honestly, narrow the dispute, and use court resources efficiently. The Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) governs almost everything involving companies, directors and shareholders.

Trial-ready is what makes a dispute settle on your terms

Filing is the start of a managed process, not a leap into the unknown. In the Supreme Court’s Commercial Court list a judge takes control early, sets a timetable, and orders the parties to mediate, often within months of pleadings closing. Discovery, expert evidence and a trial date follow only if the dispute does not settle first. We prepare every commercial matter as though it will be heard, because a claim that is trial-ready is the one that settles on the best terms. Most never reach the courtroom you see here.

Ask about your matter

What commercial litigation costs

How far the dispute runs is what drives the cost. A matter that resolves at the letter of demand or in early negotiation sits a long way below one that goes through pleadings, discovery, mediation and trial, so we push for the earliest credible exit that still gets you a fair result.

What you can recover from the other side is part of the picture too. Offers of compromise and Calderbank offers are written settlement offers that shift costs if the other side rejects them and then does worse at trial. We use them deliberately, because a well-timed offer often turns a marginal cost outcome into a good one. The first call is free, and we scope your matter on it.

Litigation funding

If the case is strong but the budget is not, litigation funding may be available. A funder pays the legal costs and takes a share of the recovery if you win. Funders look closely at the merits, the quantum, and the defendant’s ability to pay. We help clients put the case to a funder, and we negotiate the funding agreement so you keep as much of the recovery as possible.

Acting for plaintiffs and defendants

We act for both. About half our matters are claims we are running, and about half are claims defended on behalf of a Melbourne business or director. The strategy looks different on each side. Plaintiffs need to drive momentum, lock in evidence, and make settlement attractive. Defendants need to slow the matter down, find the weak point in the claim, and force the plaintiff to confront the cost of winning. We do both, and acting on both sides means we know how the other side will read your file.

Talk to a Melbourne commercial litigation lawyer today

If you have received a letter of demand, a statutory demand, or a writ, call 1800 130 120 now. If you are the one whose money is owed or whose business has been damaged, call the same number. The first call is free, the advice is direct, and you will leave the call knowing what the next step is and what it costs. Not every fight a business owner ends up in is a commercial one, and our civil lawyers in Melbourne handle the rest. GET FREE ADVICE.